Showing posts with label Art and Architecture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Art and Architecture. Show all posts

Sunday, December 5, 2010

The National Portrait Gallery

I had made a vow to save most of the major museums for this winter, when I don't anticipate wanting to walk around the city very much, but today I made an exception, because I had heard that a particular exhibit at the National Portrait Gallery had been the center of some controversy, brought upon it by the Catholic League, and had subsequently self-censored in a most shameful manner.  Naturally, I had to go investigate. 

The exhibit, for those not familiar with the story (and I will admit that not everyone follows art news or gay news as much as I do - though there are some who trounce me in one or even both categories), is Hide/Seek: Difference and Desire in American Portraiture which, despite the rather bland name, is actually fascinating.  It is an examination of the impact of sexual difference (read "non-heterosexuality") in American portraiture and runs the gamut from John Singer Sargent to Georgia O'Keeffe to Andy Warhol.  The pieces are widely varied, running the gamut from photographs to abstract art, including film.  And it is film which is the center of the controversy, because one of the film pieces, A Fire in My Belly by David Wojnarowicz, a gay artist who died from complications of AIDS in 1992, portrays a crucifix with ants crawling on it (about 11 seconds from a roughly half-hour long video).  Perhaps unsurprisingly in these polarized times, the video drew criticism from conservative politicians and pundits, among them the Catholic League (with which I have no affiliation, and for which I profess infinitesimally small sympathy), and the National Portrait Gallery, to its shame, caved and withdrew the piece.  You can read more about it here.

I doubt that I would have heard about the whole thing had it not cropped up on the Facebook monster (as much as I loathe it, it does keep me up to date on a number of things, thanks to the efforts of friends more clued in than I am), which informed me that an art-historian-friend of mine had written an article examining the symbolism behind the offending art piece.  I read it and was not only positively impressed by the article, but also resolved to see the exhibit, if for no other reason than to flip a symbolic bird to the twits at the Catholic League who, apparently, have trouble understanding the concept of free speech.  So after attending Mass at St. Patrick - to re-establish my Catholic credentials, if they were ever in doubt - I marched over to the gallery, stopping in the courtyard to have lunch and plan my afternoon.

The courtyard deserves special note - the only thing I've ever see like it is the courtyard at the British Museum, which is neat, but so is this one:


Is this not awesome?  Better still, it doubles as a conservatory, where people can lounge about (as much as one can lounge on marble, anyway) in the company of plants and have their lunch.  This is useful, because as the weather gets cold I intend to continue adventuring, but I also intend to continue to bring my lunch with me, and I'll be damned if I'm going to sit on a bench in the snow and eat my lunch.  Knowing where there are heated placed where you can eat your lunch is good indeed.

After lunch I headed up to the second floor where the special exhibits are housed, and determined that the only way I could get to Hide/Seek from where I was was to go through the section of the museum dedicated to portraits of the presidents, so I did.  Most of them are fairly unremarkable - either because they're the standard profile on a black background with few other details, or because they're presidents for whom I have little affection - but there are a couple which deserve special mention because they're prominent and important.  Here they are:

Although Washington was the president when this picture was painted and is surrounded by the grandeur of office - the background would not be misplaced in the portrait of a monarch - he stands attired in simple clothes, a visible rejection of monarchy and the claim to absolute power which Washington could easily have made (and, to be honest, he would probably have been given a dictatorship if he had wanted one).  Not that Washington is entirely devoid of feudalism - what you may not know is that his family's coat of arms provided the basis for the flag of the District of Columbia, so Washington's feudal influence continues, if not in the form of a monarchy.  Coincidentally, Washington's release of power when his time as president ended is why I cite him as my favorite when my real favorite, FDR, seems like an unwise preference to make public (big government socialist!).


Abraham Lincoln is probably my mother's favorite president (although I've never asked), Civil War historian that she is, and this is one the most famous (if not the most famous) portrait of him.  It is the image of Lincoln that we cherish - that of the melancholy thinker, burdened with the fate of nation and grappling with the moral - just as much as Washington's honor and leadership prowess.  Not everyone who manages to attain the office is worthy of it or capable of executing it properly - witness the long succession of barely semi-competent men who preceded Lincoln, for example - but Washington and Lincoln are two of the greatest, without doubt, and their portraits have places of honor in this exhibition, as well as in the American psyche.

Well, having gotten my weekly dose of patriotic idealism out of my system, let's move on to controversy, shall we?

Special exhibitions in the National Portrait Gallery cannot be photographed, presumably because they want people to buy the exhibit catalog ($45 at the museum store), so I don't have photographs, but if you click the link up near the top of this post you can see a few of the pieces and read a bit about the exhibition.  Let me say simply that I enjoyed it quite a bit, and it was well attended that afternoon, almost certainly to a higher degree than it would have been without the associated controversy.  And, by the way, that story has a [somewhat] happy ending - a gallery owner will be showing a portion of A Fire in my Belly, or you can watch it online (just click that link, and then the link in that article).  In all, the video is doubtless going to be exposed to many more people now that it's been booted from the exhibition than it would have had the assorted conservative blowhards kept their mouths shut.  Ooops!

And as a sweet, semi-patriotic finale, I passed this on my way out:
The Preamble of the Constitution made out of license plates - NEEEET!

Monday, November 15, 2010

The Capitol (at Night!)

Backdated from more than a week later...I'm a bad person (again).

This evening, when I arrived home from work, I found the first half of dinner on the table and the other half being constructed in the kitchen by J, who can cook gourmet-quality when he sets his mind to it.  We ate early, because he had been advised to see the Capitol at night.  So we walked up 4th and took a right at the mall.  Unlike yesterday, I had the good sense to bring my camera:


What most people don't know is that there are two reflecting pools - the famous one that runs from the Lincoln Memorial east, and then this one, between the Capitol and the rest of the Mall.  On the other side of the pool is a statue of U.S. Grant (probably the only memorial he's got, unless you count Grant's Tomb).  From this far away you get a lot of traffic lights - not a terribly good photo.  We ventured closer, and I tried again.
There, that's better.  Interestingly, the dome is the only part of the Capitol that gets floodlit.  I suppose I had expected it to be more like the White House, which is almost entirely illuminated:
(This is from March - I haven't actually been past the White House at night since I moved here.  Perhaps I should rectify that.)

Today, I should note, was the first day Congress was in session since the midterm elections.  As we hung out and looked around (I insisted on inspecting this fountain because I love water feature's - J doesn't), we heard sirens and looked to the north - left - and saw a cavalcade of police cars with a black van in their midst.  I wondered aloud if it were a cabinet official coming from testifying to Congress, but J thought it was too grand for a secretary, and besides, would they be testifying over the dinner hour?  It was big enough for the president, he opined.  Then I remembered that the vice president is the president of the Senate, and noted that the flag on the Senate - which indicates whether it's in session - had been taken down.  It would make perfect sense for a cavalcade to speed the vice president from the Senate to the north-west, which is where he lives (the Naval Observatory is in the northwest part of town).  So perhaps that was him.  My first brush with Washington celebrity!

We talked and observed a while longer, but then it got colder - it had been cold to start, but the wind picked up - so we walked home.  J was to leave tomorrow - he would fly out while I was at work.  Fortunately for both of us, our parting wouldn't be as unhappy as when I left Chicago (we were both torn up for days), because over the few days we've been together we've sorted a lot of things out in the best possible way.

Anyhow, the Capitol's always been neat - now it just has another layer of significance for me, which can be added to all the other layers of significance others have attached to it.  If you could see them all, the Capitol would start to look more like an onion than a legislature.  This might be awkward - who wants to take orders from an onion?

Sunday, November 14, 2010

The National Cathedral

As my readers have doubtless figured out, I'm Catholic, but my boyfriend isn't.  He's unencumbered, religiously-speaking, but has a gay uncle who is the rector of a large Episcopal church in Dallas.  I am told that this uncle applied for a position at the National Cathedral, and helped write the hymnal they use there.  I also know - no need to be told - that my boyfriend is an Anglophile of the most dedicated sort, and having seen the National Cathedral briefly in March, I know that it's trying hard to be an English cathedral.  Fortunately for those of us who like that sort of thing, it does quite well in that respect.

What may surprise you, however, is that I gave up my weekly Mass to attend the National Cathedral instead (exhibit A in the case for me being ridiculously in love with that man).  So here goes - a Catholic in the heart of Episcopal America (the National Cathedral is where the Episcopal church's presiding bishop was inaugurated, after all) - will they scent the foreigner in their midst and cast him out, with much wailing and gnashing of teeth?  Will it be a revelation that drives me from Rome to Canterbury?  Will the cathedral impress my unflappable boyfriend?  Read on to find out!

Washington National Cathedral
3101 Wisconsin Ave. NW 
Website
The National Cathedral is located, surprise surprise, in the neighborhood of Cathedral Heights (check the blog map for the exact location), and sits on a hill such that it can be seen from the platform of the National Airport Metro station (which is outdoors and on stilts a few dozen feet from the ground, but quite a ways away).  To get here from my place, take the Metro from Southwest to Chinatown, then transfer onto the Red in the direction of Shady Grove (is it shady, I wonder?).  We got off at Cleveland Park and stopped for a bite to eat (for J, not me, because I had eaten breakfast while he was in the shower).  We then walked west on Macomb St. and approached the Cathedral from it's north side (the picture on the left is from the south, which is much prettier as it gets all that lovely southern sun that I used to have in Chicago).

When we turned the corner and saw the towers of the cathedral, J was mightily impressed (there's your answer to question 3).  The National Cathedral does its level best to pass for Canterbury - you think I'm kidding, but look at this photo of Canterbury and then this one of the National Cathedral and tell me there aren't any similarities - so for my anglophile par excellence  this was absolutely great.  I like it too.

We had decided to attend the 11:15 Eucharist (not Mass, I learned - Episcopalians don't say "Mass") because it had organ and choir, and promised to be the most immersive experience.  And it was.  The service opened with the cathedral choir (men and boys, in the proper English tradition) processing in while singing a motet, continued with several excellent hymns, and concluded with a very well done organ voluntary.  In between there was chant, more boy choir, and solo organ.  I am mightily impressed, but as I said to J, one of the reasons you see this here but not in many Catholic parishes of local prominence is that the National Cathedral can afford, and can draw, a good organist, a talented choirmaster, etc.  Most Catholic churches don't have the prominence to draw such people, and even more often can't afford them.  Even some Catholic cathedrals struggle with music due to money.

The only complaint I have is that all of the hymns were pitched too low for me to sing at my best.  I've been every major voice part in the course of my musical life - I started as a boy soprano, and was subsequently "graduated" to alto because alto parts for boy choir are always harder and I was a good singer, even though I still had the voice to sing soprano (I took the change of assignment as a demotion and a personal insult, because the soprano melody line was always prettier and they got to sing the descants at Christmas).  When my voice changed, it sank all the way to bass, and I sang bass in the high school madrigal group as a freshman.  But then I began to ascend upwards again, singing second tenor as a sophomore and rising up to the elite ranks of first tenor by senior year.  I'm still a tenor - a first tenor by any choir's standards, though not by operatic standards (though, as I have no intention of pursuing a career in opera, I suppose that doesn't much matter).  The majority of men, however, are middling baritones, and it was for these men that the hymns were pitched.  This is all well and good - more people feel comfortable singing, which is great - but I don't get those soaring high notes that let me stand out from most of the other guys in the room.  Nevertheless, the portly lady standing next to me complemented me on my singing voice as the service drew to a close.  I was surprised she'd even been able to hear me, and managed little more than a bashful "thank you."

I won't acknowledge that this sort of music never occurs in Catholic churches (although I am willing to concede that you'll have more luck finding it in Europe), but the liturgy here would not happen in a Catholic church.  Most prominent among the differences is that the Episcopalians have a First Reading and a Gospel - they're missing the Second Reading which Catholics always include.  There are differences in some of the prayers, of course, and I definitely messed up the Creed, although the lady next to me didn't shoot me a glare or raise a ruckus and have the infiltrated Papist thrown out (answer to question 1).  It's times like these when I realize how attached I am to the Catholic Mass - to the point that I will recite what I know, only to notice that the rest of the congregation isn't saying what I am.  Oops!


One thing I've gotten used to in the Catholic church is homilies of moderate length and moderate impact.  The Savonarolas and fire-breathing Dominicans have been supplanted by modest parish priests with modest goals for their sermons: elaborate on the readings of the day and attempt to relate that somehow to a social problem or a moral lapse that everyday Catholics encounter/experience.  Even the remaining Dominicans don't breathe fire (see the church review for St. Dominic), and I can't remember remember the last time I heard a priest speak about Hell.  But I suppose there's something about the National Cathedral that inspires the grandiose.  Maybe it's the stained glass (above).  Or perhaps it's the vaulted ceiling, soaring pillars, and elaborate woodwork (right).  Could it be the intricate marble floors, or the painstaking (and very aesthetically pleasing) needlework of these kneeler pads?

I don't know.  And I wish I had more pictures to share with you, because I forgot my camera and had to make do with my phone, so only about half of them are free of blur.  I'll just have to return with my camera sometime.  But in any case, my point is that the sumptuousness of the cathedral evidently inspired the homilist to attempt to reach the lofty heights.  By which I mean he spoke at length on every major theme which has ever occurred in a sermon, and then attempted to link them with some scripture passages which preceded the gospel.  Not the actual reading itself, mind, but the passages which precede it.  Three quarters of an hour later (you think I'm joking, but I'm not - at least, not much), I had no idea what point he was trying to make and I was craving some lunch.  Three cheers for the apocryphal Catholic priest who, on a boiling day in August, got up to the ambo to deliver his homily, said "It's hotter than Hell in here," and got back down.

On a totally unrelated note, did you know there's a lump of moon rock in the National Cathedral?  There is, in the "Space Window," on the left.  The moon rock is actually in the window, in the middle of the dark circle in the center-top (surrounded by the white ring).  Twenty feet to the left is Woodrow Wilson.  Yes, our 28th president.  He's buried in a sarcophagus in one of the aisles of the cathedral, and is actually the only U.S. president buried in the District of Columbia.   I've always shad a soft spot for Wilson, so J looked on in bemusement while I said hello and attempted to get a photo (this is the photo I was trying to take, but mine didn't turn out.  This is what I get for going to a cathedral without a proper camera).


Now, since this isn't a Catholic church I can't really call this a church review, as I won't contemplate attending on a regular basis, but supposing I were to review it anyway...

Location: 3 when the Metro decides to cooperate (as it did today), but a 2 on days when it doesn't.  Also a 2 once the weather gets colder - the hike from the metro station to the cathedral is about a mile, which I don't want to do in sleet.

Aesthetics: 5, without a doubt.  See pictures and gushing above.

Music:  Very good indeed.  It was all pitched too low for me, but quite good nonetheless.  Give it a 4.5.

Liturgy: Not really feeling the whole "sanctity of the Mass" thing Catholics look for, and the sermon was awful.  2.5 - a 2 for the sermon, but an extra .5 for women at the altar.

That gives us 15 of 20, or an average of 3.75.  Good, but not so fantastic that I'll be converting any time soon (there's your answer to question 2).   However, the National Cathedral, it should be noted, is not funded in any way by the government or any public funds, nor is it funded by the Episcopal Church, although it is Episcopal (though you have to look pretty hard on their website to find this out).  No, the National Cathedral is supported entirely by private donations, which has meant that it has suffered greatly during the recession.  In fact, it has reduced its staff by more than half to meet budget shortfalls caused by a slump in donations.  So if you've got some money to burn and love a good cathedral - in the very best, English Gothic sense of the word - perhaps you'd consider a donation.  Doesn't matter if you're not Episcopal; this building is awesome.  So although I'm not going to convert, once my finances loosen up a bit, I may have a donation or two to make...

Thursday, September 16, 2010

Good Morning Baltimore!

Today I was in Baltimore for some training and had the opportunity to visit the old Customs House, which is an architectural jewel from the early 1900s.  I took some pictures of the paintings and other pretty things in what was once the great hall where ship captains would come to present their manifests and declare their cargo, which I promise to put up soon (tomorrow), so check this space again.  Tonight, however, I need to catch up on some sleep.

On a slightly related note, when I mentioned that I would be spending the day in Baltimore, one friend remarked "Don't get shot!"  I didn't, but today someone else did.  What's particularly disconcerting is that on our way to the customs house we saw helicopters hovering over a neighborhood off to the east - I'm almost certain that this is what they were watching.  Creepy!

EDIT (Saturday): Here are the pictures from the Customs House that I promised.

The Baltimore Customs House is a large building from the early 1900s (under construction from 1903 to 1907) in fine Beaux-Arts style.  In the early 1900s the United States was beginning to wake up to its role as a great power, and so all along the East Coast monumental customs houses like this one were constructed, so as to impress the European captains who would put in with goods from Europe.  The great powers of Europe had at the time a tendency (which some believe European nations still possess) to look down on the United States as provincial and backward.  Beautiful customs houses was one way the US attempted to remedy that (another was hosting massive public events like the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition, more commonly know as the Chicago World's Fair).

Most of the Customs House is now office space (it is no longer used as a customs house - that stuff goes on at the sea- and airport - but the main receiving hall, where those captains would come to declare what they had on their ships, has been preserved, although it was carpeted at some point).  Nevertheless, it is gorgeous.

Stepping through the tall, hardwood doors, the first thing that strikes you is the monumental scale of the room.  With the ceiling easily forty feet above the floor, this room was obviously designed to impress.  And because the ceiling is so high up curiosity naturally gets the better of you, so you look up...
...and see this...
...and this (click it to enlarge if it's not clear).  This is the central portion of the mural which is partially visible in the photo above this one.  All the painting was done by Francis David Millet, who (I was told) also did the paintings in the Wisconsin State Capitol, although I can find no corroboration of this assertion.  Millet was a talented Classicist and was friends with Augustus Saint-Gaudens (known as a sculptor).  Reading through his Wikipedia entry suggests that he was quite an interesting guy, apart from being a talented painter.  As I browsed, I came across this photo of Millet in his studio:
Guess what he's painting?  That's right - the ceiling for the Customs House!

Painting is not the only interesting feature in this jewel box of a room.  There's excellent Beaux-Arts metalwork reminiscent of the monumental style in banks that existed around the same time:
There's also exquisite plasterwork and molding surrounding those paintings, the likes of which you don't often see in this country:
Now, all this beauty has to be tempered with a bit of tragedy - isn't that always the case - and although you'd think that this room being closed to the public and unused is tragedy is enough, there's another unpleasant twist of fate associated with this room.  Millet wasn't active for much longer after he painted this room.  Why?  Because he was on the Titanic when it sank in 1912, and was one of the 1,517 people who drowned as a result.  And look what he put above the door that leads to the rest of the Customs House:
Look familiar?  It does look like the Titanic, doesn't it.  But if you were paying attention to my chronology, you have by now realized that although it appears to be the Titanic, it can't be, because the Titanic sank on its maiden voyage in 1912, and this building was finished in 1907.  It's not the Titanic, but it's another ill-fated ocean liner much like it.  Clever readers will know that several ships fit that description, among them Titanic's sister ship, Britanic, but it didn't exist before 1907 either.  It is in fact the Lusitania, which at the time of the painting was the largest ship in the world, and a pinnacle of engineering.  Millet had painted ships throughout history all around the room (you can see two of them at the top of the picture), ending with the most modern example, Lusitania, above this door.  What's tragic is that Millet died aboard a similar ship in 1912, and three years later Lusitania was torpedoed by a German U-boat off the coast of Ireland and sank in just eighteen minutes, killing 1,198 of the 1,959 passengers and crew.  This was one of the factors which eventually dragged the United States into war against some of the very European powers the Customs House had been built to impress.

Funny how these things happen, isn't it?